Something must have been wrong with my air traffic control system when I found it, because this gothic romance novel flew right in under my radar. I was delighted to find what appeared to be a trashy vampire paperback from the late 1960s and I was totally sure that it was going to be filled with weird erotic tension, and crossed my fingers, hoping that it wouldn’t have a Scooby-Doo ending. I got about twenty pages into it before I realized that it seemed like a romance novel. Panicking, I checked the front cover again, and this time the word “Gothic” jumped out at me. “How did I miss that?” I wondered. “Ah. No matter.” I thought. “Maybe this will be amusing.”
Who is Barnabas Collins?
At this point, you may be wondering, “Who is this Barnabas Collins, the vampire America loves to hate?” In short, besides being a 175 year old vampire, Barnabas Collins is a liar, a cheat, a parasite, and a cad. When he is taking advantage of the family maid, his mind is really elsewhere: Planning a later liaison with a loose woman he will meet at a tavern. He is startlingly promiscuous and an evasive cad when confronted with it. He spends most of the rest of his time coddling a broken heart and fawning over any poor crippled young lady who may by chance resemble his one lost love. His lost love, Josette, who threw herself off a cliff when she discovered his curse!
Here’s the set-up: Margaret Collins should be on top of the world. She has married into a wealthy family and runs a bustling household in 1899. Sadly, her workaholic husband is a jerk. Margaret has a beautiful daughter who was born with deformed legs and a weak heart. Still, Margaret perseveres. There is also Luke, a kind-hearted but developmentally challenged boy who is devoted to her daughter. Also on her estate, Collinwood, reside a few maids, including an elderly retired maid who has become part of the family, and who is named “Granny Erstwhile.”
Enter Barnabas Collins, who claims to be the grandson of the original Barnabas of long ago. Of course, since we all know he’s a vampire already, we are aware of the sham, but Margaret has to learn the hard way. Barnabas rents the family’s smaller original house, which exists on the grounds of Collinwood. Margaret secretly falls in love with Barnabas while he does the following:
- Lies to her all the time, even after she discovers his horrible secret.
- Vampirizes her crippled daughter.
- Murders Granny Erstwhile (who was not fooled for a minute and tried to warn everyone.)
- Vampirizes and eventually throttles Patience, one of the maids.
- Is responsible for the death of poor Luke at the hands of the local Sheriff.
- Vampirizes Margaret’s best friend, a widow who runs an orphanage.
- Adopts a sad but beautiful and innocent orphan with the intent of making her his child bride.
- Makes regular appointments with all the loose women in town.
- Unleashes Hare, his violent, unkempt, mean-tempered, perpetually drunk and disheveled butler, on the grounds of Collinwood and all who come too near.
- Sends Hare on unspeakable errands in the Collinwood graveyard.
Margaret eventually discovers his secret and a truce is forged. Margaret’s daughter, Greta, has had another attack and doesn’t have long to live. Greta has fallen under the spell of Barnabas and Barnabas fawns over her (because of her resemblance to Josette.) When confronted by Margaret, Barnabas threatens to withdraw his loving attention from Greta, which may lead to her immediate death. Margaret relents, but we know she’s secretly in love with Barnabas.
He linked his cane over the chair back and took her gently by the arms, his deep-set black eyes drilling into her. “Do you not realize you are the kind of woman I could love if things were not as they are?” he asked in a taut voice. “You have beauty, strength of character and a kind heart. Virtues I admire greatly.”
Margaret tried to avoid those hypnotic eyes, fearful of his overpowering her with his strong will. She, who had so long been the victim of a loveless marriage, was only too aware of the magnetism of this odd but handsome man. She trembled with the passion his words aroused in her along with the chilling fear she had come to feel for him.
“Please, let me go!” she whispered.
Luckily all is not lost. I’ve already spoiled enough of the novel without revealing the end. In the final analysis, I would rate this near the top of the trashy gothic romances from this era (of which I have read a handful) and was especially happy that it didn’t have a Scooby Doo ending (A Scooby-Doo ending, for the uninitiated, is the kind where the ghost or monster is unmasked in the end, and you find that he was really – for example – the janitor who was haunting the factory to keep people away while he robbed the safe “Until you kids came along and spoiled everything!”)
While researching this book I found that Barnabas Collins is alive and well! There is a movie “in development” that will star Johnny Depp as Barnabas Collins with Tim Burton directing. Barnabas Collins also has his own Wikipedia page. The Dark Shadows TV show has following too, with pages all over. There is the Dark Shadows Wiki, Dark Shadows dot com, Dark Shadows Online, and Collinwood dot net. Here is the IMDB page for the original Dark Shadows TV show. Click here to see my review of the Dark Shadows movie, House of Dark Shadows with Barnabas Collins.

Jonathan Frid as Barnabas Collins.
Creepy Factor: 2 out of 5
Suspense Factor: 2 out of 5
Weird Erotic Tension Factor: 1 out of 5
Funny and/or Strange Factor: 5 out of 5
Final result: You will not be missing anything if you pass this one over, but I love to hate Barnabas Collins!
Barnabas Collins by Marilyn Ross – Paperback Library – 1968
Barnabas Collins Book and Action Figure on Amazon
Dark Shadows DVDs and gear on Amazon
Thanks for reading another one of my book reviews. Hopefully next time I review a nice juicy horror novel with loads of Weird Erotic Tension. I’m working on it! See you next time!